Summary of “Cases and Materials on Contracts” by Farnsworth, Young, and Sanger (2020)

Summary of

Business Law and EthicsContract Law

**
“Cases and Materials on Contracts” by Farnsworth, Young, and Sanger is a comprehensive textbook widely used in law schools to teach the principles and intricacies of contract law. The book meticulously examines various elements of contract formation, performance, and enforcement through an extensive compilation of case laws, statutes, legal theories, and commentaries.

I. Introduction to Contract Law

Overview:
The book begins with an introduction to the fundamental concepts of contract law, including the definition of a contract, its purposes, and the importance of contracts in the legal system and business environment.

Concrete Example:
Case Law: The case of Lucy v. Zehmer is discussed to illustrate the objective theory of contracts. In this case, the court held that an external manifestation of intent to a reasonable observer constitutes a binding agreement, even if one party claims to have been joking.

Specific Action:
Practical Application: When entering into a contract, ensure that your words and actions manifest clear intent to create legal obligations to avoid disputes about the contract’s validity.

II. Offer and Acceptance

Overview:
The text delves into the elements of offer and acceptance, emphasizing their roles in forming a legally binding agreement.

Concrete Example:
Case Law: The book uses Raffles v. Wichelhaus to explore the concept of mutual assent and the importance of certainty in the terms of the agreement.

Specific Action:
Practical Application: Clearly specify all essential terms in your contracts. Ensure mutual understanding to avoid issues like those in Raffles, where ambiguity led to a misunderstanding about the terms of the contract.

III. Consideration

Overview:
Consideration is examined as a cornerstone of enforceable contracts, including the requirement that consideration must be something of legal value exchanged between the parties.

Concrete Example:
Case Law: Hamer v. Sidway demonstrates the principle of consideration where the court found the promise of forbearance (refraining from legal rights) to be valid consideration to enforce a contract.

Specific Action:
Practical Application: Always ensure there is an exchange of value in your contractual agreements. A mere promise without consideration is generally unenforceable.

IV. Capacity and Legality

Overview:
This section addresses the capacity of parties to contract and the legality of the contract’s subject matter. Specific rules are outlined for contracts involving minors, intoxicated persons, and mentally incapacitated individuals.

Concrete Example:
Case Law: The case of Dodson v. Shrader highlights the concept of contract enforceability concerning minors, emphasizing the “benefit rule” whereby minors must return the benefits received but not necessarily the full value.

Specific Action:
Practical Application: Verify the capacity of all parties to contract. Exercise caution in entering contracts with minors and understand the potential implications of such agreements.

V. Defenses to Contract Formation

Overview:
The book catalogs potential defenses against contract enforcement, such as fraud, duress, undue influence, and mistake.

Concrete Example:
Case Law: Sherwood v. Walker explores mutual mistake, particularly when there is a significant error regarding the substance of the contract. Here, the mistaken identity of a cow’s fertility status nullified the agreement.

Specific Action:
Practical Application: Conduct thorough due diligence to ascertain all relevant facts before entering a contract. Clearly document and verify mutual understanding to prevent potential disputes.

VI. Statute of Frauds

Overview:
The Statute of Frauds requires certain types of contracts to be in writing to be enforceable, such as contracts for the sale of land and agreements that cannot be performed within one year.

Concrete Example:
Case Law: Crabtree v. Elizabeth Arden Sales Corp. exemplifies how a combination of documents can satisfy the writing requirement under the Statute of Frauds.

Specific Action:
Practical Application: Ensure that contracts subject to the Statute of Frauds are in writing and signed by the parties. When dealing with multiple documents, make sure they clearly relate to each other.

VII. Third-Party Beneficiaries and Assignment

Overview:
The rights of third-party beneficiaries and the rules concerning the assignment of contracts and delegation of duties are thoroughly explored.

Concrete Example:
Case Law: Lawrence v. Fox establishes the principle that a third-party beneficiary can sue to enforce a contract made for their benefit, thereby recognizing their enforceable rights.

Specific Action:
Practical Application: Clearly delineate any third-party beneficiary rights within the contract. When assigning rights or delegating duties, notify all involved parties to ensure awareness and consent.

VIII. Conditions, Performance, and Breach

Overview:
The text addresses the distinctions between conditions, promises, and the consequences of breach. It examines total and partial breaches and their respective remedies.

Concrete Example:
Case Law: Hochster v. De La Tour illustrates anticipatory repudiation, allowing the non-breaching party to sue for damages immediately upon breach.

Specific Action:
Practical Application: Clearly outline conditions and performance criteria in the contract. In the face of a potential anticipatory breach, consider your options promptly to mitigate damages.

IX. Remedies

Overview:
This section explores the remedies available for breach of contract, including damages (compensatory, consequential, punitive, and nominal), specific performance, and restitution.

Concrete Example:
Case Law: Hadley v. Baxendale establishes the foreseeability rule for consequential damages, where damages must be reasonably foreseeable at the time of contract formation.

Specific Action:
Practical Application: Clearly communicate potential consequences of a breach at the time of contract formation to ensure the scope of damages is understood. When seeking remedies, evaluate the most effective course of action based on the breach’s nature and impact.

X. Evolving Issues in Contract Law

Overview:
The book concludes by discussing modern developments and emerging issues in contract law, such as electronic contracts, arbitration clauses, and international contract principles.

Concrete Example:
Case Law: Spearin Doctrine is analyzed in the context of construction contracts, addressing the liability of contractors when provided with flawed specifications by the owner.

Specific Action:
Practical Application: Stay informed about legal trends that may impact contract enforceability, especially with evolving technology and globalization. Formulate contracts to address these changes proactively.


In summary, “Cases and Materials on Contracts” serves as a vital educational tool for understanding contract law and its practical applications. Each chapter reinforces critical concepts through real-world cases and actionable advice to help students and practitioners navigate the complex landscape of contractual obligations. By integrating these principles into daily practices, individuals can draft, negotiate, and enforce contracts more effectively, minimizing legal risks and fostering reliable business relationships.

Business Law and EthicsContract Law