**
In her 2019 book, Diversity, Inc.: The Failed Promise of a Billion-Dollar Business, Pamela Newkirk critically examines the multi-billion-dollar diversity industry and its ineffectiveness in fostering genuine inclusion and equity in corporate America. Drawing from a wealth of examples, studies, and interviews, Newkirk argues that despite significant investments in diversity initiatives, meaningful progress remains elusive. This summary distills the key points of Newkirk’s work, structured around major themes and actionable steps.

Key Point: Despite substantial financial investments in diversity initiatives, there has been little tangible improvement in workplace diversity over the past few decades.

Examples:
– Many corporations spend millions on diversity training, yet statistics show that the representation of minorities in leadership positions has stagnated.
– The diversity industry, which grows annually at a rapid pace, has not significantly changed the racial demographics of many upper management teams.

Actionable Step:
– Evaluate Effectiveness: Regularly assess the impact of diversity initiatives within your organization by tracking metrics such as minority hiring rates, promotion rates, and satisfaction surveys. If there is no meaningful improvement, reconsider or revise the approach.

Key Point: Systemic and structural barriers within organizations hinder the effectiveness of diversity programs.

Examples:
– Policies that inadvertently favor networks dominated by historically privileged groups.
– Recruitment processes that are biased towards certain educational institutions, which lack diversity.

Actionable Step:
– Policy Audit: Conduct an audit of recruitment, promotion, and retention policies to ensure they are inclusive and fair. Adjust practices to remove biases that favor homogeneity.

Key Point: There is a prevalent culture of tokenism, where a few minority faces are highlighted to suggest diversity without deeper integration and support.

Examples:
– Companies that showcase a few minority employees in advertisements but fail to address systemic discrimination.
– Workplaces where minority employees feel isolated and unsupported, leading to high turnover rates.

Actionable Step:
– Create Support Networks: Establish Employee Resource Groups (ERGs) and mentorship programs that provide genuine support and foster a sense of belonging for minority employees.

Key Point: Leadership attitudes and actions are crucial in driving diversity and inclusion.

Examples:
– Cases where CEOs and top executives publicly commit to diversity, followed by clear, actionable plans, often see better outcomes.
– Conversely, companies where diversity is not a priority for leadership tend to show minimal progress.

Actionable Step:
– Leadership Commitment: Ensure that diversity and inclusion are integral components of the company’s mission statement. Executives should lead by example, participating actively in diversity training and regularly speaking out about the importance of these values.

Key Point: Diversity programs often fail because they are detached from business goals and performance metrics.

Examples:
– Training sessions that are seen as a checkbox rather than integral to business strategy.
– Lack of diversity goals tied to performance reviews and business outcomes, leading to minimal engagement.

Actionable Step:
– Integrate into Business Strategy: Tie diversity initiatives directly to business goals. Make diversity goals a part of performance reviews and reward milestones achieved in fostering an inclusive environment.

Key Point: One-time training sessions and workshops often fall short without ongoing commitment and integration into the organizational culture.

Examples:
– Annual diversity training that does not translate into everyday practices.
– Programs that are dissociated from continuous professional development and everyday business practices.

Actionable Step:
– Continuous Learning: Implement ongoing diversity education and integrate it into professional development programs. Ensure that diversity training moves beyond compliance and is reflected in daily practices and culture.

Key Point: Genuine diversity and inclusion enhance organizational productivity and innovation.

Examples:
– Studies show that diverse teams perform better due to a wider range of perspectives and problem-solving approaches.
– Companies with diverse leadership teams often outperform those without in terms of financial returns.

Actionable Step:
– Champion Diversity as a Strength: Promote and communicate the tangible benefits of diversity in terms of productivity and innovation, ensuring all employees understand the strategic importance.

Key Point: Public accountability can drive organizations to take diversity seriously.

Examples:
– Transparency in reporting diversity metrics can spur companies to improve their practices.
– Public commitments and reporting against goals can create a competitive environment that rewards genuine diversity progress.

Actionable Step:
– Publish Diversity Reports: Regularly publish diversity and inclusion reports that detail the composition of the workforce, hiring practices, and progress towards goals. This can foster public accountability and a culture of transparency.

Key Point: Mandatory training sessions often provoke resistance and fail to bring about meaningful change.

Examples:
– Research indicating that compulsory diversity training can lead to backlash and entrench negative attitudes.
– Companies where mandatory training led to minimal behavioral change.

Actionable Step:
– Voluntary Engagement: Foster a culture where diversity and inclusion training is seen as an opportunity for personal and professional growth rather than a mandatory task. Encourage voluntary participation and provide incentives for attendance.

Key Point: Grassroots efforts and bottom-up approaches are often more effective than top-down mandates.

Examples:
– Employee-led initiatives that address specific needs and challenges faced by underrepresented groups.
– Success stories where grassroots movements within companies led to substantial cultural shifts.

Actionable Step:
– Empower Employees: Provide platforms for employees to voice their concerns and lead initiatives. Encourage bottom-up approaches and support them with resources and recognition.

Key Point: Approaches to diversity must consider the intersectionality of race, gender, sexuality, disability, and other identities.

Examples:
– Programs that focus narrowly on one dimension of diversity (e.g., race) without considering the interconnected experiences of other marginalized groups.
– Intersectional initiatives that address multiple facets of identity and thus achieve more comprehensive inclusion.

Actionable Step:
– Adopt an Intersectional Approach: Develop and implement diversity initiatives that acknowledge and address the interconnectedness of various identity dimensions. Offer training on intersectionality to ensure a nuanced understanding among employees.

Pamela Newkirk’s Diversity, Inc. underscores the importance of reevaluating and enhancing the way organizations approach diversity and inclusion. By recognizing the limitations of current practices and embracing a more comprehensive, committed, and strategic approach, organizations can move closer to fulfilling the true promise of diversity.

By following the actionable steps outlined based on Newkirk’s insights, individuals and organizations can work towards creating genuinely inclusive environments that not only acknowledge but also celebrate and leverage diversity for broader success and equity.