Summary of “Earned Value Project Management” by Quentin W. Fleming and Joel M. Koppelman (2016)

Summary of

Operations and Supply Chain ManagementProject Management

Introduction

“Earned Value Project Management” by Quentin W. Fleming and Joel M. Koppelman, published in 2016, offers a detailed and pragmatic approach to earned value management (EVM), a comprehensive method for tracking and validating project performance and progress. EVM integrates three critical components of project management: scope, time, and cost, enabling project managers to evaluate and understand project health effectively. This structured summary delves into key points and actionable steps based on concrete examples from the book.

1. Basics of Earned Value Management

Major Point: Earned Value (EV) is a central metric within EVM that assesses the amount of work actually completed compared to the planned work.

Example: A construction project plans to complete 40% of the work by the third month. If 45% of the work is completed, the EV helps determine this completion level.

Actionable Step: Regularly measure EV by setting up milestone dates where the project team conducts reviews of work progress relative to planned schedules.

2. Fundamental Metrics in EVM

Major Point: EVM uses specific metrics, such as Planned Value (PV), Earned Value (EV), and Actual Cost (AC), to assess project performance.

  • Planned Value (PV): Budgeted value assigned to work scheduled.
  • Earned Value (EV): Budgeted value of completed work.
  • Actual Cost (AC): Actual expenditure for completed work.

Example: By month three on a software development project, PV is calculated at $50,000, EV at $45,000, and AC at $55,000.

Actionable Step: Establish and maintain a project baseline that clearly defines PV, enabling accurate tracking and comparison of EV and AC throughout the project lifecycle.

3. Performance Indicators

Major Point: Key performance indicators derived from EVM include Cost Performance Index (CPI) and Schedule Performance Index (SPI).

  • Cost Performance Index (CPI): EV/AC, indicating cost efficiency.
  • Schedule Performance Index (SPI): EV/PV, indicating schedule adherence.

Example: In the software project, CPI = 45,000/55,000 = 0.818, and SPI = 45,000/50,000 = 0.9. This suggests the project is over budget and slightly behind schedule.

Actionable Step: Calculate CPI and SPI at regular intervals. If CPI < 1 or SPI < 1, investigate and address underlying issues causing inefficiencies or delays.

4. Variance Analysis

Major Point: Variance analysis involves the evaluation of Cost Variance (CV) and Schedule Variance (SV).

  • Cost Variance (CV): EV – AC, indicating cost deviation.
  • Schedule Variance (SV): EV – PV, indicating time deviation.

Example: CV = 45,000 – 55,000 = -10,000, showing a negative cost variance; SV = 45,000 – 50,000 = -5,000, showing a negative schedule variance.

Actionable Step: When negative variances are identified, implementing corrective measures such as revising schedules or reallocation of resources can help realign the project.

5. Forecasting Using EVM

Major Point: EVM enables forecasting future performance with metrics like Estimate at Completion (EAC) and Estimate to Complete (ETC).

  • Estimate at Completion (EAC): Expected total cost, calculated as AC + (BAC – EV), where BAC is Budget at Completion.

Example: If BAC for a project is $120,000, then EAC = 55,000 + (120,000 – 45,000) = $130,000, predicting an over-budget scenario.

Actionable Step: Use EAC to anticipate final project costs and make informed decisions about budgetary adjustments.

6. Implementing EVM in Project Management

Major Point: Successful EVM implementation requires organizational commitment and skilled project management.

Example: A pharmaceutical company adopting EVM for new drug development sets clearly defined processes for PV, EV, and AC tracking, ensuring consistent performance measurement.

Actionable Step: Train project management teams in EVM principles and establish robust tracking systems to ensure accurate data collection and analysis.

7. Integrating EVM with Project Planning

Major Point: Integrate EVM into initial project planning by defining a Work Breakdown Structure (WBS) and assigning budgetary values accordingly.

Example: In a marketing campaign project, the team develops a WBS that includes distinct tasks such as market research, content creation, and campaign launch, each with allocated budgets.

Actionable Step: Create a comprehensive WBS early in the project planning phase and assign PV to each task, aligning it with the overall project timeline.

8. EVM and Risk Management

Major Point: EVM supports proactive risk management by identifying variances and enabling timely corrective actions.

Example: In a government project, risk assessments identified potential delays due to regulatory approvals. EVM monitoring revealed deviations early, prompting risk mitigation strategies.

Actionable Step: Conduct regular risk assessments and integrate EVM data to detect and respond to risks promptly.

9. Use of EVM Tools and Software

Major Point: Utilize project management software that supports EVM to streamline data tracking and reporting.

Example: A tech firm uses specialized EVM software, providing real-time dashboards for PV, EV, and AC, which facilitates quick decision-making and project adjustments.

Actionable Step: Invest in and implement EVM-compatible software to enhance data accuracy and accessibility for project managers and stakeholders.

10. Continuous Improvement with EVM

Major Point: EVM can drive continuous improvement by providing insights into project performance trends and enabling iterative enhancements.

Example: An automobile manufacturer uses EVM data from previous projects to refine budgeting and scheduling practices, improving efficiency in subsequent projects.

Actionable Step: Analyze EVM trends from completed projects to identify and apply lessons learned in future project planning and execution.

Conclusion

“Earned Value Project Management” by Fleming and Koppelman (2016) emphasizes the importance of integrating EVM practices into project management to achieve better control and visibility over project performance. By understanding and applying the EVM metrics and principles—such as EV, PV, AC, CPI, SPI, and variance analysis—project managers can make informed decisions, anticipate challenges, and implement strategic adjustments effectively, resulting in successful project outcomes.

By adhering to the actionable steps provided in the book, organizations can enhance their project management capabilities, align projects with strategic objectives, and foster a culture of continuous improvement.

Operations and Supply Chain ManagementProject Management