Summary of “HBR’s 10 Must Reads on Innovation” by Harvard Business Review (2013)

Summary of

Innovation and CreativityLeadership and ManagementTechnological InnovationInnovation Leadership

HBR’s 10 Must Reads on Innovation (2013) by Harvard Business Review is an anthology that aggregates ten seminal articles on innovation leadership and technological innovation. The curated selection provides a comprehensive examination of various dimensions of innovation, offering insights, frameworks, and practical advice for business leaders seeking to cultivate and manage innovative processes successfully. Below is a structured summary of the book, highlighting its major points, action steps, and illustrative examples.


1. The Discipline of Innovation – Peter F. Drucker

Main Points:
– Innovation as a systematic discipline.
– Sources of innovative opportunities, including unexpected occurrences and process needs.

Examples:
– Drucker emphasizes that successful innovators often look for unexpected successes or failures in their industry (e.g., Honda’s unexpected success with the Super Cub motorbike in the US).

Action Steps:
– Regularly analyze anomalies in business outcomes and explore them for potential innovation opportunities.
– Conduct a review of existing processes to identify inefficiencies that could be addressed through innovation.


2. The Innovation Catalysts – Roger L. Martin

Main Points:
– Role of innovation catalysts within organizations.
– Importance of having dedicated individuals to drive and manage the innovation process.

Examples:
– Procter & Gamble’s use of Design Thinking to foster innovation illustrates how having dedicated “catalysts” can transform the organization’s innovation pipeline.

Action Steps:
– Appoint innovation catalysts within your team to champion and facilitate innovation initiatives.
– Provide training on design thinking to these catalysts to enhance their effectiveness.


3. Innovation: The Classic Traps – Rosabeth Moss Kanter

Main Points:
– Common pitfalls in innovation, such as focusing on bureaucratic processes rather than fostering creativity.
– The necessity of balancing structure and freedom to spur innovation.

Examples:
– Kanter discusses how large organizations often stifle innovation by enforcing rigid processes that limit creative thinking, referencing Kodak’s failure to adapt to digital photography due to organizational inertia.

Action Steps:
– Encourage a culture of experimentation and flexibility within your organization.
– Reduce bureaucratic obstacles that hinder the creative process and promote cross-functional collaboration.


4. How GE is Disrupting Itself – Jeffrey R. Immelt, Vijay Govindarajan, and Chris Trimble

Main Points:
– Concept of reverse innovation where innovations are first developed in emerging markets and then introduced to developed markets.
– The importance of adapting and learning from diverse market environments.

Examples:
– GE’s development of a portable, low-cost ultrasound machine for China and India, which later found innovative applications in the US healthcare market.

Action Steps:
– Identify emerging market needs and develop innovative solutions tailored to these markets.
– Experiment with introducing these innovations in developed markets to identify new opportunities.


5. Connect and Develop: Inside Procter & Gamble’s New Model for Innovation – Larry Huston and Nabil Sakkab

Main Points:
– Importance of open innovation and leveraging external sources for ideas and technologies.
– Shift from research & development to connect & develop.

Examples:
– P&G’s approach to sourcing 50% of its innovations from outside the company by collaborating with a vast array of external experts and organizations.

Action Steps:
– Establish networks and partnerships with external innovators, including academics, startups, and other enterprises.
– Create an internal platform to facilitate the integration of external ideas into the company’s innovation pipeline.


6. The Ambidextrous Organization – Michael L. Tushman and Charles A. O’Reilly III

Main Points:
– Balancing the exploration of new opportunities (innovation) with the exploitation of existing capabilities (efficiency).
– Creating structures that allow for both exploratory and exploitative activities.

Examples:
– IBM’s ability to innovate while maintaining its core businesses by setting up autonomous units focused on new growth areas, such as e-business.

Action Steps:
– Designate separate teams for exploring new innovations and optimizing current operations.
– Develop mechanisms for these teams to collaborate and share insights to integrate new innovations without disrupting ongoing business processes.


7. Is It Real? Can We Win? Is It Worth Doing? – George S. Day

Main Points:
– Framework to evaluate the potential of innovation projects using R-W-W (Real-Win-Worth).
– Criteria to assess technical feasibility, market viability, and strategic alignment.

Examples:
– Day’s case study on Pfizer’s analysis of potential projects using the R-W-W framework helps prioritize innovation initiatives based on their potential for success and alignment with business goals.

Action Steps:
– Apply the R-W-W framework to screen and prioritize innovation projects in your organization.
– Regularly revisit and reassess projects to ensure they continue to meet the criteria for success as new information becomes available.


8. The Customer-Centered Innovation Map – Lance A. Bettencourt and Anthony W. Ulwick

Main Points:
– Innovating by focusing on customer jobs-to-be-done rather than product features.
– Mapping out the entire customer experience to identify points for innovation.

Examples:
– Intuit’s success with QuickBooks, which was designed by understanding the full range of jobs small business owners needed to manage their finances efficiently.

Action Steps:
– Conduct detailed customer journey mapping to uncover unmet needs and pain points.
– Redesign products and services to better align with customers’ jobs-to-be-done.


9. Blue Ocean Strategy – W. Chan Kim and Renée Mauborgne

Main Points:
– Creating new market spaces (blue oceans) rather than competing in existing ones (red oceans).
– Value innovation as the cornerstone of blue ocean strategy.

Examples:
– Cirque du Soleil’s reinvention of the circus by combining elements of theater and high-quality performance, creating an uncontested market space.

Action Steps:
– Identify factors that your industry competes on and determine which can be eliminated, reduced, raised, or created anew to find blue ocean opportunities.
– Brainstorm ways to deliver exceptional value and create a niche market.


10. Innovation Killers: How Financial Tools Destroy Your Capacity to Do New Things – Clayton M. Christensen, Stephen P. Kaufman, and Willy C. Shih

Main Points:
– Overreliance on financial tools like discounted cash flow can hinder innovation.
– Understanding the limitations of traditional financial metrics when evaluating innovation projects.

Examples:
– The authors illustrate how companies such as Apple have succeeded by looking beyond short-term financial metrics, investing in future-oriented innovation like the development of the iPhone.

Action Steps:
– Develop alternative metrics to assess the value of innovation projects, focusing on strategic and long-term potential.
– Create a balanced portfolio of innovation investments, including high-risk, high-reward projects.


Conclusion

HBR’s 10 Must Reads on Innovation provides invaluable insights for fostering innovation within organizations. By systematically integrating these strategies, leaders can cultivate a robust innovation culture that balances creativity with practical implementation, adapts to emerging markets, leverages external partnerships, and creates uncontested market spaces. Practical actions such as establishing dedicated innovation champions, conducting customer journey mapping, and reassessing financial evaluation methods ensure that innovative initiatives are not just successful but also sustainable.

Innovation and CreativityLeadership and ManagementTechnological InnovationInnovation Leadership