Summary of “Intellectual Property in the New Technological Age” by Robert P. Merges, Peter S. Menell, Mark A. Lemley (2016)

Summary of

Business Law and EthicsIntellectual Property

**
Introduction
“Intellectual Property in the New Technological Age” by Robert P. Merges, Peter S. Menell, and Mark A. Lemley is a comprehensive guide exploring the intersections of intellectual property (IP) law with rapidly evolving technological landscapes. The authors delve deeply into the nuances of IP law amidst new technological advancements, providing historical contexts, current practices, and future directions. The book covers patents, copyrights, trademarks, trade secrets, and the implications of digital information on IP law.

1. Historical Context and Foundations

A. Development of Intellectual Property Law
The authors trace the evolution of IP laws from their historical origins to the present day. They explain how these laws were formulated to encourage innovation and creativity by granting limited-time monopolies.

B. Examples:
– The Statute of Monopolies (1623) which laid early groundwork for patent law.
– Introduction of the Copyright Act of 1790 in the United States, protecting books, maps, and charts.

Actionable Step:
Anyone interested in IP law should familiarize themselves with its historical context to better understand contemporary legal landscapes and anticipate future changes.

2. Patent Law

A. Fundamentals of Patent Law
The book discusses the criteria for patentability, including novelty, non-obviousness, and utility. It also covers the processes involved in obtaining a patent and enforcing patent rights.

B. Examples:
– The case of Diamond v. Chakrabarty (1980), where the Supreme Court allowed patenting of genetically modified organisms, highlighting how technological advances push the boundaries of patent law.
– Software patents and their increasing significance, such as the Microsoft and Apple lawsuits over graphical user interfaces.

Actionable Step:
When pursuing a patent, an individual or company should extensively document their innovation, ensuring it meets all criteria, and consult with a patent attorney to navigate the complexities of the application process.

3. Copyright Law

A. Basics of Copyright Protection
The book details what constitutes copyrightable works, including literary, musical, and artistic works. It also explains the rights granted to copyright holders and the duration of these rights.

B. Digital Friction:
With the advent of the internet, digital copying and distribution have complicated copyright enforcement. The authors emphasize the importance of the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA) in combating digital piracy.

C. Examples:
– The case of Napster and its impact on the music industry.
– Google Books litigation involving the digitization of copyrighted works.

Actionable Step:
Content creators should consider using digital rights management (DRM) tools and services to protect their works against unauthorized distribution, and stay informed about changes in legislation that could impact their rights.

4. Trademark Law

A. Trademark Fundamentals
The authors explain the purpose of trademarks in distinguishing goods and services, the criteria for obtaining a trademark, and the importance of maintaining distinctive marks.

B. Trademark Infringement and Dilution:
The book discusses issues related to trademark infringement, where unauthorized use of a mark causes confusion, and trademark dilution, where the distinctiveness of a famous mark is weakened.

C. Examples:
– The case of Coca-Cola v. Koke Co., illustrating trademark protection against infringement.
– Google Inc. v. American Blind & Wallpaper Factory, dealing with keyword advertising and trademark use.

Actionable Step:
Businesses should perform thorough trademark searches before adopting a new brand name, logo, or slogan to avoid potential infringement issues and ensure their trademarks are registered and maintained properly.

5. Trade Secrets

A. Nature of Trade Secrets
The book provides an overview of trade secret law, which protects confidential business information that gives a competitive edge. It explains the requirements for maintaining trade secrets and the legal recourse available for trade secret misappropriation.

B. Examples:
– The case of DuPont v. Christopher, where aerial photographs were used to uncover manufacturing secrets, leading to a landmark trade secret ruling.
– The controversy surrounding the Coca-Cola formula and its meticulous protection measures.

Actionable Step:
Companies should implement robust confidentiality agreements, establish clear internal policies for handling sensitive information, and use technological measures to safeguard their trade secrets.

6. New Technological Challenges

A. Biotechnology and IP
The book highlights how advances in biotechnology pose new challenges and opportunities for IP law. The authors discuss patentability issues related to genetic material and biotech innovations.

B. Software and IP
The authors elaborate on the complexities of protecting software through patents, copyrights, and trade secrets, and the varying jurisdictions’ stances on these protections.

C. Examples:
– The case of Myriad Genetics concerning the patentability of human genes.
– Open source software models used by companies like Red Hat and their impact on traditional IP paradigms.

Actionable Step:
Innovators in biotechnology and software should stay abreast of evolving legal standards and consider hybrid protection strategies, including patents, copyrights, and trade shares.

7. International Perspectives

A. Global Harmonization
The book discusses the international dimensions of IP law, stressing the importance of agreements like the Agreement on Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights (TRIPS) in promoting a consistent global IP framework.

B. Regional Variations and Enforcement
The authors address how different countries’ IP laws can impact multinational IP strategies and the enforcement challenges that arise in international contexts.

C. Examples:
– Differences in software patentability between the US and the European Union.
– International treaty implications on IP, such as the Berne Convention for the Protection of Literary and Artistic Works.

Actionable Step:
Businesses operating internationally should develop a comprehensive IP strategy that aligns with the IP laws of each jurisdiction where they operate and participate in global IP forums to influence policy developments.

8. Policy and Reform

A. Critiques and Recommendations
The authors provide critical analyses of the current IP system, addressing issues like patent thickets, copyright term extensions, and the balance between protection and public access.

B. Future Directions
The authors suggest reforms aimed at fostering innovation while ensuring equitable access to information and technology.

C. Examples:
– The problem of patent trolls and proposed legislative reforms such as the Innovation Act.
– Debates over fair use doctrine and its implications for education and transformative works.

Actionable Step:
Stakeholders should engage in policy advocacy and participate in public consultations to help shape future IP reforms that strike a balance between proprietary rights and public interests.

Conclusion
“Intellectual Property in the New Technological Age” offers a thorough examination of IP law in the context of technological advancements. It provides practical guidance for navigating the complexities of IP protections, enforcement, and policy implications. By understanding historical contexts, current challenges, and future directions, stakeholders can proactively manage their IP assets and contribute to a balanced and dynamic IP landscape.

Business Law and EthicsIntellectual Property