Summary of “Issues in International Commercial Law” by Iwan Davies (2005)

Summary of

Business Law and EthicsInternational Trade Law

**
Introduction

“Issues in International Commercial Law” by Iwan Davies is a comprehensive exploration of the complexities and key issues in international trade law. It provides a detailed examination of the legal framework governing international commerce and the many challenges faced by practitioners in this field. The book is structured to guide the reader through various topics, from dispute resolution mechanisms to the intricacies of trade finance, offering practical actions and case studies to illustrate these issues.

1. Dispute Resolution in International Trade

Major Points:
– The book highlights the importance of effective dispute resolution mechanisms in international trade.
– Arbitration is emphasized as a preferred method for resolving international commercial disputes due to its flexibility and enforceability under the New York Convention.
– Mediation is discussed as an alternative to arbitration, offering a less adversarial and often more cost-effective resolution method.

Concrete Example:
– The ICC (International Chamber of Commerce) Arbitration is cited as a prominent example where businesses often turn to resolve complex disputes.

Specific Action:
– To mitigate risk, businesses should include clear arbitration clauses in their international contracts specifying the jurisdiction and applicable rules.

2. International Sale of Goods

Major Points:
– The United Nations Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods (CISG) is analyzed as a critical treaty governing international sales.
– The book discusses the advantages and drawbacks of CISG and its impact on contract formation, obligations of parties, and remedies for breach.

Concrete Example:
– A scenario is presented involving a German seller and a French buyer where the CISG provisions helped resolve a dispute regarding non-conforming goods shipment.

Specific Action:
– Companies should familiarize themselves with the CISG provisions and explicitly state in their contracts whether the CISG will apply to avoid any unintended legal consequences.

3. Trade Finance

Major Points:
– Various instruments of trade finance, such as letters of credit, bills of exchange, and documentary collections, are explained.
– The book examines how these instruments facilitate international trade by providing security to both buyers and sellers.

Concrete Example:
– A case study is provided on a Chinese exporter and an American importer using a letter of credit to ensure payment and timely delivery of goods.

Specific Action:
– Exporters and importers should use letters of credit for transactions with new or less-trusted trading partners to secure payment and reduce risk.

4. Intellectual Property in International Trade

Major Points:
– Intellectual property rights (IPR) are crucial in international trade, protecting innovations and brands.
– The Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights (TRIPS) Agreement under the WTO sets minimum standards for IPR protection globally.

Concrete Example:
– The book details a dispute involving counterfeit software shipped from India to the USA and how TRIPS provisions were used to resolve it.

Specific Action:
– Businesses should ensure that their intellectual property is registered and protected in all major markets they operate in.

5. Carriage of Goods by Sea

Major Points:
– The legal responsibilities and liabilities of parties involved in the shipping of goods are addressed.
– The Hague-Visby Rules and the Hamburg Rules are compared concerning the carriage of goods by sea.

Concrete Example:
– An example involving a damaged cargo shipped from Brazil to Italy is used to illustrate how the Hague-Visby Rules govern liability for damage.

Specific Action:
– Parties should explicitly state in their contracts the choice of governing rules for the carriage of goods by sea to ensure predictable liability outcomes.

6. Electronic Commerce

Major Points:
– The rise of electronic commerce and its implications for international trade are examined.
– Issues such as electronic contracts, signatures, and data protection are discussed.

Concrete Example:
– A case study involves an international e-commerce transaction where the validity of an electronic signature was contested.

Specific Action:
– Companies engaged in international e-commerce should adopt technology that complies with international standards for electronic signatures and data protection.

7. International Trade Sanctions

Major Points:
– The impact of trade sanctions and embargoes on international trade is analyzed.
– The book discusses compliance with international sanctions regimes and the importance of due diligence.

Concrete Example:
– A scenario is presented where a UK company inadvertently breached US sanctions by exporting to Iran, leading to significant penalties.

Specific Action:
– Businesses should implement robust compliance programs to ensure they do not engage in trade with sanctioned entities or countries.

8. International Competition Law

Major Points:
– The convergence and divergence of competition laws in different jurisdictions and their impact on multinational corporations are examined.
– The book discusses cases where differing competition laws in the EU and US have affected mergers and acquisitions.

Concrete Example:
– The merger between US-based Google and a European tech company is used to illustrate the different regulatory hurdles encountered.

Specific Action:
– Firms planning international mergers or acquisitions should conduct thorough antitrust analyses in all affected jurisdictions to anticipate and address regulatory challenges.

9. Environmental Regulations in International Trade

Major Points:
– The intersection of international trade and environmental protection is addressed.
– The book discusses the role of international agreements like the Kyoto Protocol in regulating trade practices to protect the environment.

Concrete Example:
– An example of how environmental regulations affected the export of chemicals from the USA to the EU is provided, illustrating compliance challenges.

Specific Action:
– Exporters should stay informed about environmental regulations in target markets to ensure compliance and avoid penalties.

10. Emerging Markets and Trade Law

Major Points:
– The book explores the unique challenges and opportunities associated with doing business in emerging markets.
– Topics such as political risk, cultural differences, and underdeveloped legal infrastructures are discussed.

Concrete Example:
– A scenario involving a Western multinational entering the Indian market is used to highlight challenges related to contract enforcement.

Specific Action:
– Businesses looking to enter emerging markets should conduct political risk assessments and develop strategies to mitigate legal and cultural challenges.

Conclusion

“Issues in International Commercial Law” by Iwan Davies provides a broad and nuanced understanding of the many facets of international trade law. It not only discusses the theoretical frameworks but also provides practical advice through real-world examples and actionable steps. This makes it a valuable resource for legal practitioners, businesses engaged in international trade, and scholars interested in understanding the complexities of international commercial law.

References

Davies, Iwan. “Issues in International Commercial Law.” (2005).

Business Law and EthicsInternational Trade Law