**
I. Introduction to Moral Imagination

Moral Imagination: The Core Concept
At the heart of Patricia H. Werhane’s book lies the concept of moral imagination, which she defines as the ability to envision various possible issues, consequences, and solutions in ethical decision-making. This involves stepping outside of established frameworks to see beyond routine practices and recognize ethical dimensions that may not be immediately apparent.

Action Step: Cultivate awareness and mindfulness in everyday situations to enhance the ability to recognize and consider ethical aspects.

II. Understanding Ethical Frameworks

Moral Imagination vs. Routine Choices
Werhane points out how decision-making in corporate settings often falls back on habitual and conventional frameworks, which can obscure ethical considerations. She argues that ethical dilemmas require managers to break out of these molds and approach problems creatively and morally.

Example: Enron’s scandal serves as a case study where failures in moral imagination led to the overlooking of unethical accounting practices that ultimately brought down the company.

Action Step: Regularly challenge and reassess standard operating procedures and corporate norms to identify potential ethical blind spots.

III. Integrative Sketch of Moral Imagination

Components of Moral Imagination
Werhane proposes a four-component model for moral imagination in decision making: a) Reproductive imagination, b) Productive imagination, c) Creative imagination, and d) Empathy.

Reproductive Imagination
This involves recognizing established patterns and existing norms. It is the ability to recall and identify the standard operating procedures, business practices, and cultural norms that are often taken for granted.

Action Step: Maintain a repository or journal that documents typical decision-making processes and their outcomes for reflective analysis.

Productive Imagination
This is the process of reconstituting and restructuring existing norms to envision novel perspectives and scenarios. Selection of alternative approaches can lead to innovative solutions.

Action Step: Periodically hold brainstorming sessions that explicitly encourage out-of-the-box thinking in addressing both routine and complex problems.

Creative Imagination
Going beyond productivity, creative imagination involves formulating entirely new solutions that break away from traditional paradigms. It is about envisioning what can be created rather than merely modified.

Example: Werhane elaborates on how IBM reimagined itself from a hardware company into an all-encompassing technology solutions firm, ensuring long-term viability and ethical progress.

Action Step: Foster an organizational culture that rewards creative problem-solving and recognizes employees who bring forward radical, positive innovations.

Empathy
Empathy entails understanding and appreciating the positions and feelings of other stakeholders, which informs a more compassionate and holistic approach to decision-making.

Action Step: Encourage managers and employees to practice active listening and engagement with diverse stakeholder groups to better appreciate varying perspectives.

IV. Applying Moral Imagination in Practice

Case Studies and Practical Examples
To ground moral imagination in real-world scenarios, Werhane provides multiple case studies.

Example: She discusses the Merck case, where the company decided to pursue the development of the drug Mectizan to treat river blindness, despite the lack of immediate financial benefits. The choice underscores the importance of moral imagination in achieving sustainable ethical solutions.

Action Step: Establish decision-making committees that explicitly consider ethical implications for both immediate and extended future scenarios.

Example: In the case of Volvo and its decision to create seatbelt-friendly cars, Werhane exemplifies how companies can leverage moral imagination not just for compliance but for setting industry standards and leading ethical advancements.

Action Step: Promote ethical leadership by setting high moral benchmarks within the company, encouraging others in the industry to follow.

V. Overcoming Barriers to Moral Imagination

Challenges in Implementation
Werhane acknowledges that there are significant barriers to employing moral imagination. Cognitive biases, organizational cultures resistant to change, and the pressures of short-term profit objectives can impede ethical decision-making.

Example: The Challenger Space Shuttle disaster serves as a grim reminder of how ignoring ethical considerations in favor of meeting deadlines can have catastrophic consequences.

Action Step: Implement regular ethics training and workshops aimed at identifying and mitigating cognitive biases and fostering a more ethically aware culture.

VI. Restructuring Corporate Culture

Creating an Ethical Climate
A significant portion of Werhane’s argument stresses the need to cultivate an ethical corporate culture where moral imagination can flourish.

Action Step: Develop and enforce a robust corporate code of ethics that includes guidelines for ethical conduct and decision-making, supported by an open-door policy for reporting ethical concerns.

Example: She highlights Starbucks’ practice of emphasizing social responsibility as part of their core values, demonstrating how a company can integrate ethics into its business model effectively.

Action Step: Integrate ethical considerations into the company’s mission statement, performance evaluations, and overall strategic planning process.

VII. Evaluating Moral Outcomes

Metrics and Accountability
It’s vital to assess the effectiveness of decisions made using moral imagination to ensure they meet ethical standards and organizational goals.

Example: Werhane cites Johnson & Johnson’s Tylenol crisis as an example where appropriate metrics and accountability ensured the company’s ethical responses were effective, leading to regained consumer trust.

Action Step: Develop clear metrics for evaluating both the ethical and business outcomes of decisions, ensuring that there is accountability at all levels of the organization.

VIII. Conclusion and Future Directions

The Ongoing Role of Moral Imagination
Werhane concludes by reiterating the necessity of institutionalizing moral imagination within the managerial decision-making process. She emphasizes that ethical business practices are not just reactive measures but proactive engagements that require continuous effort.

Action Step: Commit to lifelong learning and development in ethical decision-making for all employees through ongoing education, seminars, and industry best practices.

By systematically integrating moral imagination into the fabric of organizational culture and decision-making processes, companies can navigate the often complex intersections of ethics and business, ultimately leading to more sustainable and responsible success.