Innovation and CreativityBusiness Model Innovation
Introduction
Henry Chesbrough’s “Open Business Models,” published in 2006, explores the paradigm shift from traditional, closed business models to open business models in the era of globalization and rapid technological change. This book falls under the category of Business Model Innovation and offers practical insights into how companies can innovate by leveraging external ideas and technologies alongside internal capabilities. Below is a structured summary of the book, including key points, concrete examples, and specific actions one can take based on the advice provided.
1. The Changing Landscape of Innovation
Key Point:
The traditional, closed innovation model is no longer sufficient for sustaining competitive advantage. Companies need to adopt open innovation practices to remain relevant.
Example:
Procter & Gamble’s “Connect + Develop” initiative epitomizes this shift. Instead of relying solely on internal R&D, P&G actively seeks ideas, technologies, and products from external sources to drive innovation.
Action:
Evaluate External Opportunities – Companies should conduct systematic scans of their external environment to identify potential collaboration partners, technologies, or innovations that can complement their existing capabilities.
2. Defining Open Business Models
Key Point:
An open business model allows firms to use external and internal ideas to create value and share that value with other firms who can also use it, thereby forming a value network.
Example:
IBM’s decision to open-source its Eclipse software platform demonstrates how open business models can create value. By giving away the core of Eclipse, IBM attracted a large community of developers, which, in turn, drove innovation and growth of complementary products and services.
Action:
Develop Open Platforms – Companies should consider how they can create and manage open platforms, encouraging external innovation while also harvesting the benefits of a collaborative ecosystem.
3. The Role of Intellectual Property (IP) in Open Innovation
Key Point:
IP management is crucial in an open innovation model. Firms need to balance protecting their intellectual assets while also engaging in knowledge sharing and collaboration.
Example:
Qualcomm’s licensing model showcased how strategic licensing of IP could drive revenue and spur industry-wide growth. By licensing its CDMA technology, Qualcomm enabled widespread adoption and innovation within the wireless communication industry.
Action:
Adopt Strategic IP Policies – Firms should develop and implement IP policies that promote strategic licensing and partnerships, carefully balancing protection and openness.
4. Business Model Experimentation
Key Point:
To succeed with open business models, companies must be willing to experiment with different business models and adapt quickly based on feedback and changing market conditions.
Example:
Google’s AdSense program is an example of business model experimentation. Initially, Google’s revenue came from licensing search technologies, but experimenting with an advertising-based model dramatically increased its revenue and market reach.
Action:
Institute an Experimentation Culture – Organizations should encourage departments to test new business models on a small scale before wider implementation, promoting a culture of continuous innovation and improvement.
5. Creating Value through Networks
Key Point:
Value creation in open business models often comes from forming networks or ecosystems where multiple parties can create and capture value jointly.
Example:
Apple’s App Store is an exemplary model of creating value through networks. By allowing third-party developers to create apps for its devices, Apple has built a vast ecosystem that enhances the value of its products and services.
Action:
Build and Nurture Ecosystems – Companies should focus on building strong, dynamic ecosystems around their core products or services, encouraging third-party contributions and participation.
6. Leveraging External Incubation and Acquisition
Key Point:
Firms can strengthen their innovation capacity by acquiring startups or forming strategic alliances with smaller, agile companies that have pioneered new technologies or business models.
Example:
Cisco Systems’ acquisition strategy has been pivotal to its success. Cisco has acquired numerous companies that have developed critical networking technologies, thereby maintaining its market leadership.
Action:
Pursue Strategic Acquisitions – Regularly identify and evaluate startups or smaller firms that offer complementary technologies or business models, which can be integrated into the larger organizational strategy.
7. Redefining the Role of R&D
Key Point:
In an open business model, the role of internal R&D shifts from solely generating in-house innovations to also identifying, integrating, and commercializing external innovations.
Example:
Xerox PARC’s transition from a closed R&D lab to a more open model where it collaborates with external partners illustrates how internal R&D can facilitate open innovation. Despite Xerox benefiting in the 1970s, most of the innovations from PARC resulted in more value to companies like Apple and Microsoft.
Action:
Revamp R&D Objectives – Adjust the focus of R&D departments from only generating proprietary ideas to also sourcing external innovations and integrating them into the company’s product development processes.
8. Business Model Portfolios
Key Point:
Companies should manage a portfolio of business models rather than relying on a single model. This approach allows for more flexibility and resilience in a rapidly changing business environment.
Example:
Philips Electronics operates various business models across its healthcare, lighting, and consumer electronics divisions, ensuring the company stays resilient to changes in each market.
Action:
Diversify Business Models – Develop and manage a diverse set of business models tailored to different segments or markets, ensuring flexibility and risk mitigation across the organization.
Conclusion
Henry Chesbrough’s “Open Business Models” presents a compelling case for why and how companies should transition from closed to open business models. By leveraging external ideas and innovations, fostering collaborative networks, and managing strategic IP, companies can create more value and sustain competitive advantage. The action points derived from the book offer a practical roadmap for organizations aiming to implement open business models successfully.