Business Law and EthicsContract Law
**
Introduction
Keith A. Rowley’s “Questions & Answers: Contracts” is a practical guide designed to aid law students in understanding and applying the principles of contract law. This comprehensive guide is filled with a wide range of questions and detailed answers, allowing readers to test their knowledge as they study. Each major point of contract law is covered with concrete examples to illustrate the principles and mechanisms at work. Below is a structured summary of the book.
1. Formation of Contracts
The formation of contracts is a foundational concept in contract law, involving offer, acceptance, and consideration.
-
Offer and Acceptance:
Concrete Example: A seller offers to sell a bicycle for $100. The offer is clear and definite.
Specific Action: When making an offer, ensure it is clear, definite, and communicated directly to the offeree. -
Consideration:
Concrete Example: A promise to paint a house in exchange for $500 is consideration; both parties are providing something of value.
Specific Action: Ensure that the exchange involves mutual consideration; each party must promise or provide something of value.
2. Defenses to Contract Formation
Several defenses can invalidate a contract, including incapacity, duress, undue influence, fraud, misrepresentation, and mistake.
-
Incapacity:
Concrete Example: A minor entering into a contract to buy a car can disaffirm the contract due to lack of legal capacity.
Specific Action: Always verify the legal capacity of the parties involved in the contract. -
Fraud and Misrepresentation:
Concrete Example: If a seller lies about the mileage of a car to induce the buyer to purchase it, the buyer can void the contract.
Specific Action: Carefully investigate and verify all critical information about the transaction and parties before finalizing the contract.
3. Statute of Frauds
Certain types of contracts must be in writing to be enforceable, including contracts for the sale of goods over a certain amount and contracts that cannot be performed within one year.
-
Contracts for Goods Over $500:
Concrete Example: A contract for the sale of furniture worth $600 must be in writing to be enforceable under the Statute of Frauds.
Specific Action: Ensure that contracts for goods exceeding the threshold amount are documented in writing. -
One-Year Rule:
Concrete Example: A two-year employment contract must be in writing to be enforceable.
Specific Action: Document any agreements that cannot be performed within one year in writing.
4. Third Party Rights and Obligations
Third-party rights and obligations in contracts can arise through assignments, delegations, and third-party beneficiary contracts.
-
Assignments:
Concrete Example: A landlord assigns the right to receive rent to a bank; the tenant must now pay rent to the bank.
Specific Action: Clearly document any assignment agreements to avoid disputes. -
Third-Party Beneficiaries:
Concrete Example: A father contracts with a service provider to pay for his child’s college education; the child is the third-party beneficiary.
Specific Action: Clarify the status of third-party beneficiaries within the contract terms to ensure their rights are protected.
5. Performance and Breach
Performance and breach of contract are key areas dealing with how parties fulfill their contractual obligations and what happens if they fail to do so.
-
Substantial Performance:
Concrete Example: A builder completes most of a house-building contract but leaves minor issues unfinished; this may be seen as substantial performance.
Specific Action: Strive for substantial performance in fulfilling contract obligations and address any deficiencies proactively. -
Anticipatory Breach:
Concrete Example: If a seller notifies the buyer in advance that they will not be able to deliver the goods as agreed, it constitutes anticipatory breach.
Specific Action: In the event of anticipatory breach, notify the other party immediately and explore remedy options, such as seeking damages or contract termination.
6. Remedies
Remedies for breach of contract can include damages, specific performance, and restitution.
-
Damages:
Concrete Example: If a contractor fails to complete a project causing the homeowner to hire another at a higher price, the homeowner can claim the difference in cost as damages.
Specific Action: Keep detailed records of losses incurred due to breach to substantiate claims for damages. -
Specific Performance:
Concrete Example: For unique goods like rare art pieces, the court may order the seller to deliver the specific item instead of monetary compensation.
Specific Action: Seek specific performance when monetary compensation is inadequate to remedy the breach.
7. Impracticability and Frustration of Purpose
These doctrines excuse performance when unforeseen events make contractual obligations significantly more difficult or impossible to perform.
-
Impracticability:
Concrete Example: A supplier’s factory burns down, making it impossible to fulfill a contract to deliver goods; may constitute impracticability.
Specific Action: Include clauses in contracts to address potential impracticable situations and communicate promptly if such events occur. -
Frustration of Purpose:
Concrete Example: Renting a hall for an event that gets canceled due to a government ban on gatherings may frustrate the contract’s purpose.
Specific Action: Review the contract terms and engage the other party to negotiate adjustments or termination in light of the frustrated purpose.
8. UCC and Common Law Distinctions
The Uniform Commercial Code (UCC) governs contracts for the sale of goods, while common law generally governs service contracts and real estate transactions.
-
UCC Application:
Concrete Example: A contract for the sale of 100 widgets is governed by the UCC, which provides gap-filling provisions if certain terms are missing.
Specific Action: Specify the applicability of the UCC in contracts involving the sale of goods, ensuring compliance with its provisions. -
Common Law Principles:
Concrete Example: A service contract to provide IT support is governed by common law principles that differ from the UCC’s approach.
Specific Action: Adhere to common law principles in service contracts, detailing terms to avoid reliance on potentially ambiguous common law doctrines.
Conclusion
Keith A. Rowley’s “Questions & Answers: Contracts” offers vital insights and practical advice for understanding contract law. By examining the formation, defenses, Statute of Frauds, third-party rights, performance, breach, remedies, impracticability, frustration of purpose, and the distinctions between UCC and common law, readers will be better equipped to navigate contract complexities. Implementing the specific actions recommended in the book can lead to more effective and legally robust contracts.