Summary of “Term Sheets & Valuations: An Inside Look at the Intricacies of Term Sheets & Valuations” by Alex Wilmerding (2001)

Summary of

Entrepreneurship and StartupsFunding and Investment

Introduction

“Term Sheets & Valuations” by Alex Wilmerding offers a detailed examination of the key aspects involved in the venture capital funding process. The book specifically delves into the intricacies of term sheets and valuations, providing invaluable insights for entrepreneurs and investors alike. It stands out for its practical examples and actionable strategies, making complex concepts accessible and understandable.

Chapter 1: Understanding Term Sheets

Major Points:

  1. Definition and Purpose of Term Sheets:
  2. Term sheets are preliminary agreements that outline the terms and conditions under which an investment will be made.
  3. They are not legally binding, except for specific sections like confidentiality and exclusivity.

  4. Components of a Term Sheet:

  5. Economic terms include aspects like valuation, price per share, and the amount of investment.
  6. Control terms cover things like voting rights, board composition, and protective provisions.

Examples and Actions:

  1. Clear Valuation Metrics:
  2. Example: The book stresses the importance of understanding pre-money and post-money valuation. If a company is valued at $5 million pre-money and a VC invests $1 million, the post-money valuation is $6 million, making the investor’s share 16.67%.
  3. Action: Entrepreneurs should calculate both pre-and post-money valuations beforehand to set clear expectations during negotiations.

  4. Negotiating Board Composition:

  5. Example: Wilmerding describes a scenario where retaining founder control required negotiating three out of five board seats.
  6. Action: Founders should prioritize retaining enough seats on the board to ensure they have significant influence over company decisions.

Chapter 2: Economic Terms in Detail

Major Points:

  1. Valuation and Pricing:
  2. The importance of getting the right valuation based on the stage of the company and market conditions.
  3. Price per share is calculated by dividing the pre-money valuation by the number of existing shares.

  4. Liquidation Preferences:

  5. Liquidation preference determines how proceeds are distributed in the event of a liquidation, sale, or bankruptcy.
  6. Participating and non-participating liquidation preferences affect how returns are distributed between investors and founders.

Examples and Actions:

  1. Fair Price per Share:
  2. Example: A company valued at $10 million pre-money with 1 million shares outstanding would have a price per share of $10.
  3. Action: Entrepreneurs should perform due diligence to find comparable company valuations to justify their proposed pricing.

  4. Negotiating Liquidation Preferences:

  5. Example: Wilmerding shows an example of a 1x non-participating liquidation preference versus a 2x participating preference.
  6. Action: Founders should advocate for a 1x non-participating liquidation preference to align investor and founder interests better.

Chapter 3: Control Terms and Protections

Major Points:

  1. Voting Rights:
  2. Voting rights determine who has the power to make significant company decisions.
  3. Different classes of shares may have different voting rights (e.g., common vs. preferred).

  4. Anti-Dilution Provisions:

  5. These provisions protect investors from dilution in future rounds by adjusting conversion prices of preferred shares.

Examples and Actions:

  1. Class of Shares:
  2. Example: Preferred shares might carry extra voting rights compared to common shares to give investors more control.
  3. Action: Companies should clearly outline the rights of different share classes in the term sheet to manage expectations.

  4. Full Ratchet vs. Weighted Average Anti-Dilution:

  5. Example: Full ratchet adjustment can drastically reduce founders’ equity in down rounds, whereas weighted average is a softer adjustment.
  6. Action: Founders should negotiate for weighted average anti-dilution provisions to minimize potential equity loss.

Chapter 4: The Valuation Process

Major Points:

  1. Qualitative and Quantitative Factors:
  2. Both subjective factors like market potential, team quality, and competitive landscape, as well as financial metrics, influence valuations.

  3. Due Diligence:

  4. Comprehensive due diligence is critical, including financial audits, customer references, and technology evaluations.

Examples and Actions:

  1. Qualitative Assessments:
  2. Example: A strong, experienced team might command a higher valuation due to perceived execution ability.
  3. Action: Entrepreneurs should highlight their team’s strengths and prior successes during valuation discussions.

  4. Thorough Due Diligence:

  5. Example: A venture capital firm might discover important insights from customer references that significantly affect valuation.
  6. Action: Companies should prepare in advance for due diligence by organizing financial records and securing customer commitments for positive references.

Chapter 5: Case Studies and Real-World Applications

Major Points:

  1. Successful Negotiation Tactics:
  2. Real-world examples illustrate successful strategies for negotiating favorable term sheets and valuations.

  3. Common Pitfalls and How to Avoid Them:

  4. Identifying and learning from common mistakes made during term sheet negotiations.

Examples and Actions:

  1. Leveraging Multiple Offers:
  2. Example: A startup received multiple term sheets and used this leverage to negotiate better terms, such as lower dilution and higher valuation.
  3. Action: Founders should seek multiple investors to create a competitive bidding environment, yielding better terms.

  4. Avoiding Misalignment:

  5. Example: Misalignment between founders and investors on exit strategies resulted in conflicts and a failed venture.
  6. Action: Ensure alignment on long-term goals and exit strategies with investors during the negotiation phase to prevent future conflicts.

Conclusion

Alex Wilmerding’s “Term Sheets & Valuations” is a comprehensive guide that breaks down the complexities of venture capital investment into digestible parts. The book emphasizes clear definitions, real-world examples, and actionable advice, making it an essential read for anyone involved in funding and investment. Entrepreneurs, in particular, can benefit greatly from its insights, enabling them to negotiate more favorable terms and achieve better outcomes for their ventures.

Entrepreneurship and StartupsFunding and Investment